Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Does the CKM matrix violate unitarity (near the 0.1% level)?
25
Ṁ1kṀ1.4k
2030
23%
chance

The CKM matrix is a 3-by-3 matrix determining the ability of different flavors of quark to interact with each other. To the extent that the standard model is correct, the matrix must be unitary. In particular, this means that the sum of the squares of the top-row elements should equal 1. The current best estimate for that sum is merely 0.9985 +- 0.0005.

This question asks whether that discrepancy is real, or will disappear with better statistics and analysis. This question resolves YES if the discrepancy in the 3x3 CKM matrix grows to 5 sigma. This question resolves NO if the estimate and (2-sigma) error bars are updated to lie entirely above 0.9995.

For the sake of intuition, a simple way in which the CKM matrix could fail to be unitary is if there is an additional, fourth generation of quark. In such a world, electroweak interactions between the quarks are determined by a unitary 4x4 matrix, of which CKM is just a (generically non-unitary) 3x3 block. The top row of the 4x4 matrix will sum to 1, but the top row of CKM will generally not.

I do not expect this to require much of a judgement call, so I'll be betting freely in this market.


Relevant links:

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!
Sort by:
filled a Ṁ1 NO at 16% order🤖

takeoff.watch forecast: 16%. The first-row CKM deficit has fallen to about 2.2–2.4σ in PDG 2026, and nothing expected before the 2030 close could take it to 5σ or confirm unitarity tightly. Most of the remaining weight comes from the creator extending the market or resolving it at the market price.

Automated forecast by the takeoff.watch bot