Manifold Plays: 25 Questions [spin-off] [Ṁ1000 prize] [final attempt]
31
1k
3.2k
resolved Nov 6
Resolved
YES
Can it be held in one's hand?
Resolved
YES
Is it made of organic matter?
Resolved
YES
Is it made of wood?
Resolved
YES
Does it usually cost less than $100?
Resolved
N/A
Is it made to contain things?
Resolved
N/A
Will it blend?
Resolved
N/A
Is it a toy?
Resolved
N/A
Is it primarily used outdoors?
Resolved
10%
Is it made of, or does it contain, plastic?
Resolved
NO
Is it made of, or does it contain, metal?
Resolved
NO
Can it be found in an office?
Resolved
NO
Is it alive?
Resolved
NO
Can it be found in a typical home?
Resolved
NO
Is it decorative?
Resolved
NO
Is it made of, or does it contain, paper?
Resolved
NO
Can an animal use it like how a human usually use it?
Resolved
NO
Do people usually hold it in hand while using it?
Resolved
NO
Is it an abstract concept?
Resolved
NO
Is it fictional?
Resolved
NO
Is it a tool?

I'm thinking of a thing. You have a week and at most 25 Yes-or-No questions to figure out exactly what thing it is.

Here's a hash of a phrase containing the answer: 9a44247296effd745a6af7e0eb3dbc7cc8bb23fe2111f384f2f83ddf46fa58414453a92666ff8b96517b37694e9cebf6e718e5bf58aee593057557515229ed9c

If you get it right, you win!

I've put in a few questions, but you'll have to add your own from here on out.


I was inspired heavily by this market by @Stralor: /Stralor/manifold-plays-twenty-questions


The Rules

A couple of times per day at my discretion, I'll answer ̶a̶n̶y̶ ̶n̶u̶m̶b̶e̶r̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶q̶u̶e̶s̶t̶i̶o̶n̶s two questions (with highest and lowest probability) about the thing which will get at least 3 likes/hearts ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶w̶i̶l̶l̶ ̶t̶r̶a̶d̶e̶ ̶a̶t̶ ̶l̶e̶s̶s̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶n̶ ̶2̶6̶%̶ ̶o̶r̶ ̶h̶i̶g̶h̶e̶r̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶n̶ ̶7̶4̶%̶ (starting with those with more likes). In order for that to work you should write a comment in context of your newly added answer (see the button on the right side of the bet button). That comment can be anything in order to count (for example: a dot), but it's a good place to write some thoughts. If you'd like to require more likes before the question is resolved, then write this explicitly in that comment (max. requirement is 10). Comment threads can be used for discussion.

Valid questions are those that can be resolved YES or NO and are new info. They don't need to be properly written, but it must be clear to me what's going on. Examples:

"Is it round?"

"ball"

"uhh i think maybe its the eiffel tower"

"is it a DOG or a CAT?!?" ⚠️ but careful, this one would be answered YES or NO without further explanation

If there's tricky compound logic, multiple questions in one, it's a troll answer, or I just can't understand the intent of it clearly, it isn't a valid question and will either be ignored or resolved N/A with prejudice.

However, if it's valid but I feel neither YES or NO is wholly correct, I will resolve PROB and not count it as one of your 25.

Resolution

🎉 If one of the questions I answer is the thing: 🎉

  • WILL YOU WIN? resolves YES

  • Bonus: M$1000 prize to the person whose question got it right

😭 If you don't guess the exact thing within 25 answers: 😭

  • WILL YOU WIN? resolves NO

All remaining questions will resolve N/A.

Get Ṁ200 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ400
2Ṁ166
3Ṁ79
4Ṁ45
5Ṁ39
Sort by:

"And the answer is... drumroll... a goban!" (also known as a go board)

Too bad it didn't work out ☹

@MrLuke255 That's a tough one

Will it blend?

This option didn't have a comment yet

This option didn't have a comment yet

Is it primarily used outdoors?

This option didn't have a comment yet

It's already 19 questions answered!

box

Is it made to contain things?

🥣

I've changed rules a bit and added this new option. After this week the game is over no matter if someone guesses right or not.

bought Ṁ5 of Answer #74cb9561838a NO

@MrLuke255 will"you"win? The you is like"you guys" rather than you as in "you personally" who votes on the comment. I voted no, I won't win, nobody will win

@VAPOR Why so negative 😒

@MrLuke255 it was a question by the way, was it like 'will "y'all" win?'

@VAPOR It's based on @Stralor's idea. It resolves according to the description, when someone adds a correct answer and it's resolved by me before 25 questions are already resolved (not counting resolved to prob)

I think this option didn't have its own thread (it has now)

It's not a deck of cards!

bought Ṁ50 of Answer #83a3c25bd09c NO

Closing in less than 11 hours

@MrLuke255 very unfortunate that no one wants to play in the second week

Is it made of wood?

we know it is made of organic matter, so this seems like a good bisection

@SavioMak Yeah, I was actually waiting for that to be confirmed before submitting one like this.

bought Ṁ10 of Is it made of wood? YES

Paper is made of wood, so that should cover that case as well

@Shump agreed. but what organic matter is not wood? it would have to be cloth, something pretty obscure, or a stretch like downstream oil products like rubber

You're right. Also paper is already at 3, so let's let that resolve first. I'd stay there's still a decent chance of something made from cloth (fits the 10% plastic because synthetics exist). Oil products wouldn't count as organic matter though, right? Otherwise plastic also counts as organic material, which is really weird since these are molecules that don't exist in nature.

@Shump I would think that oil would count as organic. Oils are lipids, one of the main types of organic molecules.

@JosephNoonan Oil as in cooking oil, yes. Oil as in gasoline, less so. Oil products like plastic and rubber are definitily not composed of organic molecules though

Perhaps you guys should suggest another question instead if this question isn't good enough. Btw, the category of organic matter depends on whether you use a common sense definition of organic or the chemistry definition where basically everything with carbon is organic. I'm not sure which one Luke used.

@Shump I'm refer to things that still contain oil, rather than being processed into different chemicals. So it would also include stuff like gasoline. Plastic could be excluded, depending on the definition of organic matter.

I think rubber definitely counts as organic, though. It can be harvested from trees. Though maybe only certain rubbers should count.

@SavioMak Yes, it is made of wood!