In which formats will any MH3 cards be banned by EOY?

125Ṁ2782

Jan 1

ALL

99.0%

Legacy

Pauper

Commander

Resolved

YES

Modern

Only counts if the card is banned after release, not at or before release. In the case of reprints, it only counts if the card was added to the format via MH3. For example, if Orim's Chant is banned in Modern and Legacy (and nothing else is) this market resolves Yes for Modern and No for Legacy. The banlist update must go into effect during 2024 to count, a change announced in 2024 but implemented in 2025 is not enough.

Clarification Aug 9: For the digital format Historic, where cards are frequently rebalanced rather than banned outright, this market only concerns itself with bans. A 'suspension' is for all intents and purposes a ban.

Magic: The Gathering

Card Games

Get

1,000

to start trading!

People are also trading

Which MTG cards will be banned in standard before rotation?

How many Modern Horizons 3 cards will be banned in Modern by the end of 2025?

Which Magic: The Gathering cards will be banned from Standard this year?

In 2025, will a Magic: The Gathering card be banned within 4 weeks of becoming legal in a format?

35% chance

In 2025, will a Magic: The Gathering card be banned within 2 weeks of becoming legal in a format?

9% chance

Will another Manifold Partner be banned before EOY 2025?

31% chance

Will another Moderator be banned by EOY 2025?

24% chance

Which cards will be re-banned in Modern within two years (before Dec. 16, 2026)?

Will any of the Magic: The Gathering "culturally insensitive cards" be reprinted or unbanned by the end of 2026?

6% chance

Will any of my Magic cards be stolen before the end of 2025?

Sort by:

bought Ṁ218 YES

@MartyDettmann psychic frog was banned in legacy resolves YES

@Ziddletwix @MartyDettmann I think there are still market answers unresolved. How can we free the mana?

@Quroe oh can wait 24h for ping creator then ping mods

This will take some effort to research as there have been bans since the year's end. This doesn't seem like a simple Scryfall search.

@Quroe well if someone wants to do the research that would be great! and much appreciated

if it falls to mods it shouldn't be too bad? https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Banned_and_restricted_cards/Timeline

legacy: yes bc psychic frog

commander: IIUC, there have been no commander bans in 2025. but at a glance, i'd think Nadu in september would count for YES here? so i'm not sure why it was low? might be missing something.

pauper: between may & EOY, looks like the bans were all that glitters, stickers/attractions, & cranial ram. IIRC stickers/attractions were about the un-sets, & while cranial ram is MH3, it was pre-banned before release & the rules here say that doesn't count. so NO?

so currently i'd plan to resolve legacy/commander YES (psychic frog/nadu), pauper to NO. lmk if I made a mistake. (particularly bc I don't know why commander was at 3%)

@Ziddletwix I guess we all banished Nadu to the "repressed memory" parts of our brains. I too was in the wrong side of that trade.

Modern can be resolved "yes"

filled a Ṁ100 YES at 30% order

@MartyDettmann Guide of Souls, Ocelot Pride, and Galvanic Discharge were nerfed in Historic, which is the typical rebalancing remedy for the format. Resolve?

I should have perhaps put this in the description explicitly but for the purposes of this market only bans count. These days they mostly rebalance cards but Historic does in fact have a ban list and cards are still being added to it, although from MH3 it's been only the pre-bans so far, which I excluded specifically because at least the pitch elemental ban was obviously coming.