Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Will Manifold show who tipped a comment how much when hovering over the tip amount by end of October?
19
Ṁ220Ṁ850
resolved Nov 2
Resolved
NO

This market will resolve if any of the following are true:

- If the current time is past 2022-10-31 11:59:59

It will resolve based on the following decision tree:

- If the human operator agrees:

- Resolves to round(MKT).

- Otherwise, a manually provided value

Note that the bot operator reserves the right to resolve contrary to the purely automated rules to preserve the spirit of the market. All resolutions are first verified by the human operator.

The operator also reserves the right to trade on this market unless otherwise specified. Even if otherwise specified, the operator reserves the right to buy shares for subsidy or to trade for the purposes of cashing out liquidity.

Market context
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#TraderTotal profit
1Ṁ91
2Ṁ28
3Ṁ14
4Ṁ11
5Ṁ8
Sort by:

This market is resolving because of the following trigger(s):

  • Resolve True if the current time is past 2022-10-31 11:59:59, otherwise resolve False (-> YES)

It will follow the decision tree below:

  • If the human operator agrees:

    • Resolves to round(MKT) (-> False)

Final Value: NO

predictedNO

Hell yes, resolution explanations work! Now it's just a question of changing the formats a bit

Not sure I understand exactly how this bot is working, but it looks like the answer to the underlying question will be NO. At least, I don't see who tipped when I hover over a tip...

@Boklam The generated explanations are more confusing than helpful, it turns out. I think this won't be true when it adds specific context, like how each rule is currently resolving. It was originally intended to explain "why am I resolving this way", and the comment API just became available, so I was doing it that way before

predictedNO

@LivInTheLookingGlass Ummm thanks for your reply! but I'm still confused, so let me try to actually ask the right question this time!

Will this market resolve the way I think it should, given only the question in the header?

In other words: It looks to me like this is a market that's going to be resolved by a bot, pretty much only on the basis of current market value -- but with some possibility of override by a human. Is the human actually going to determine the true answer to the question and resolve accordingly?

In still other words: Am I betting only on whether Manifold implements this feature, or am I also betting on the outcome of some robotic resolution algorithm? (Or is part of the game that you can't tell me what exactly I'm betting on?)

predictedNO

@Boklam You are betting on the headline question

Really happy that my automatic creation is mostly working. For some reason it's not grabbing the URL at the end, but that's much better than before

Now to work through integrating it to the rest

@LivInTheLookingGlass The description says this will resolve to MKT, is that accurate?

@wasabipesto Oh I see from the other market now, not sure I like that mechanic. If it's asking you for confirmation either way, why can't you just tell it whether or not the change was actually implemented?

predictedYES

Yeah, this confusion makes it clear that I really need to change that. Next on my list is now to make a rule that asks the operator directly

Description updated to the new template