Will the Republicans control the US House after the 2024 election?
Will the Republicans control the US House after the 2024 election?
85
350𝕊5727
resolved Nov 18
Resolved
YES

This question resolves after the Associated Press projects which party will control the United States House following the 2024 US general election and all relevant runoff/special elections.

This question resolves YES if the Republican Party will be in control, or NO otherwise. This question will wait to resolve until 48 hours after the house majority has been called by the AP, to ensure that the call is not retracted.


  • If there are independents/3rd party winners that are known to be intending to caucus with a major party (GOP or Democrats), they will be included as part of party control.

  • If at the time of the general election there are already scheduled special elections on which control hinges, or a runoff is triggered by the general election, this question will wait for those to resolve.

This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1𝕊161.09
2𝕊115.90
3𝕊67.23
4𝕊51.05
5𝕊25.59


Sort by:
4mo

Sweepcash version still not resolved :(

4mo

@ManifoldPolitics Can you resolve the Sweepcash version as well?

Well, Matt Gaetz apparently HAS now resigned before the start of congress. Not sure AP retracts the call because of this but 🤷‍♂️

4mo

Called by AP, let the 48 hour countdown commence. Thank you!

4mo

Alaska is almost certain to flip Republican.

As it stands, the election will head to a ranked-choice runoff. Even if Peltola receives all votes from 4th place and below, she would still be short of 50%. So, it must come down to redistributing the third-party votes for John W. Howe (AIP), who received 11k first-choice votes. Nick Begich would need less than 3k second-choice votes to win the runoff. This is likely to happen given the nationalist conservative position of the AIP.

4mo

There is rumbling on Twitter right now about Republicans losing too many seats in the short term due to Trump cabinet picks

4mo

@makeworld won’t matter for this market, they won’t leave congress until confirmed

4mo

The market has to wait until 48 hours after the Associated Press' call, as stated in its description. The Associated Press has not called the House yet.

4mo

@Calibrate Seems a little excessive. The AP calls thousands of races per year and I can only find a couple examples where they miscalled races in the last decade. Do you really want to make every wait 48 hours on the 1 in 10,000 chance the AP is wrong?

4mo

@GG in the cases where it's stated in the market description that we wait, it's policy here to wait. Market creators that don't want to wait that long can just state it resolves to AP call, in which case it can resolve early and reresolve in the rare cases where AP changes their call

4mo

@Bayesian I understand you gotta resolve the market the way you say you're gonna resolve it, but that just pushes the question back. Why does a question from an official Manifold account have a 48 hour delay? Resolving immediately on the AP call would tie the your winnings/losses to the breaking news, amplifying its dopamine rush. It's not nearly as fun to collect your winnings two days later. And in the 1 in 10,000 chance that you have to unresolve the market when the AP retracts their call...well now you've taken my dopamine on a roller coaster!

4mo

I was curious, so I looked at the 18 remaining uncalled House races. There are 13 currently uncalled races where Democrats have at least a slim chance of winning:

  • CA-39 (Takano, currently D+12)

  • CA-49 (Levin, currently D+3)

  • OR-05 (Bynum, currently D+3)

  • CA-09 (Harder, currently D+2)

  • CA-27 (Whitesides, currently D+2)

  • CA-21 (Costa, currently D+1)

  • CA-47 (Min, currently D+<1)

  • OH-09 (Kaptur, currently D+<1)

  • ME-02 (Golden, proceeding to runoff v. Theriault)

  • AZ-06 (Engel, currently Ciscomani R+<1)

  • CA-45 (Tran, currently Steel R+2)

  • CA-13 (Gray, currently Duarte R+3)

  • CA-41 (Rollins, currently Calvert R+3)

To control the House, Democrats would need to win all 13 of the above, plus one additional race from this set (which I believe is exceedingly unlikely):

  • CA-22 (Salas, currently Valadao R+7)

  • CO-08 (Caraveo, currently Evans R+<1 with the vast majority of votes in)

  • IA-01 (Bohannan, currently Miller-Meeks R+<1 with the vast majority of votes in)

  • AK-01 (Peltola, proceeding to runoff v. Begich, will almost certainly lose)

Democrats have already lost these uncalled races:

  • WA-04 (Republican vs. Republican)

4mo

@Calibrate

It's worth comparing this to the individual seat markets on the US Election tab:

ME-02 is almost guaranteed D

OR-05 and OH-09 are safe D

Most of the unfinished CA seats are likely D, except for:

CA-41, CA-45, CA-13 (all at ~30% D), and CA-22 (5% D)

AZ-06 is likely R (85%)

CO-08, IA-01 are safe R (95%)

AK-01 is likely R (10%)

I'm inclined to agree with all of these assessments.

The CA seats are all correlated, and probably also weakly correlated with AZ-06.

I think a D victory is extremely unlikely but not literally inconceivable (1-2%).

4mo

@Anthem Huh, interesting. Better trade R on that AK-01 market, then! It's worth noting that in 2022, a majority of voters preferred Begich to Peltola (52.6% to 47.4%), but Peltola won as Sarah Palin eliminated Begich from the race before the final runoff.

4mo

Anyone hoping for a quick resolution may be disappointed: with the appointment of Elise Stefanik (R, NY-21) to Trump's cabinet, there's a small possibility that this question remains unresolved until after a special election is held to replace Stefanik, which could take months.

4mo

@Calibrate I'm not sure if this is true? She would only leave congress after she is confirmed by the senate for the position, no?

4mo

@benshindel I think you may be right! Sorry about that.

4mo
bought Ṁ20 NO4mo

4mo

@Robincvgr miscalibrated.

bought Ṁ100 NO4mo

@Riley12 Do tell

4mo

Imagine waiting three days to find out who won the Super Bowl.

4mo

@GG Imagine if the Super Bowl was decided by votes. (This comment is all in good fun.)

What is this?

What is Manifold?
Manifold is the world's largest social prediction market.
Get accurate real-time odds on politics, tech, sports, and more.
Or create your own play-money betting market on any question you care about.
Are our predictions accurate?
Yes! Manifold is very well calibrated, with forecasts on average within 4 percentage points of the true probability. Our probabilities are created by users buying and selling shares of a market.
In the 2022 US midterm elections, we outperformed all other prediction market platforms and were in line with FiveThirtyEight’s performance. Many people who don't like betting still use Manifold to get reliable news.
ṀWhy use play money?
Mana (Ṁ) is the play-money currency used to bet on Manifold. It cannot be converted to cash. All users start with Ṁ1,000 for free.
Play money means it's much easier for anyone anywhere in the world to get started and try out forecasting without any risk. It also means there's more freedom to create and bet on any type of question.
© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules