Will the songs in Speak Now (Taylor’s Version) improve upon the originals?
Mini
3
32
resolved Aug 1
Resolved
YES

Speak Now (Taylor's Version) comes out on July 9th, 2023. It will be Taylor Swift's third re-recorded album. Recently I have been coerced into listening to and rating all Taylor Swift songs for social reasons, and Speak Now is the album with the highest average rating according to my spreadsheet.

The sound is what tends to change most between original albums and re-recordings. Sometimes the instruments change, and Taylor always sounds older on the re-recordings (obviously). She also tends to have less energy but more mature vocals and more control over her voice. For the other two albums she has re-recorded, I would say that the re-recordings are better than the originals. Fearless (Taylor's Version) was more interesting and sounded better than Fearless and Red (Taylor's Version) sounded less...plasticky? But Speak Now already sounds good vocally and from the one snipped from Mine (Taylor's Version) that's been released, I think it sounds worse than the original (less energetic, mostly).

This market resolves to the percentage of songs on Speak Now (Taylor's Version) which are also on Speak Now or Speak Now Deluxe which are superior to the original version (as judged by me). I will not allow for any ties between songs; I will declare one "better" than the other.

Input from my friends and others will be taken into consideration.

Get Ṁ1,000 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ11
Sort by:

The final result was thus after deliberation and consulting with others (who were not quick to get their opinions back to me):

Upgrades:

Mine

Sparks Fly

Speak Now

Never Grow Up

Enchanted

Innocent

Last Kiss

Long Live

Superman

Downgrades:

Back to December

Dear John

Mean

The Story of Us

Better Than Revenge

Haunted

Ours