Midjourney can draw stacks of colored shapes any time through 11/2023
Mini
8
769
resolved Dec 4
Resolved
NO

Right now midjourney fails rather badly at this. Examples below.

The claim is: before EOY 2023, I can run this prompt "a red triangle on a blue cube" and get success in midjourney at least 15/20 times. Right now it appears to be quite random. I will run the prompt 5x to produce 4 images and use my judgment to evaluate.

If it appears mj is specifically tuned to this, I will vary the colors/shapes/order to verify if it's a real capability or not, although that is very unlikely to be necessary.

Here is a new competitor, Ideogram's version of the image:

These all make sense - the triangle hasn't morphed into a triangular pyramid. And it's on a cube, and the cube is visible. Arguably 4/4 success.

Color flip version: also great.

Midjourney V5.2 version from 8/28/2023 - note that it's ignoring color swapping. In addition to completely ignoring color swap, these also all fail to show a cube.

All of these would fail for me.

Get Ṁ1,000 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ79
2Ṁ45
3Ṁ41
4Ṁ8
5Ṁ4
Sort by:
predicted NO

I count 2 clear successes, 1 maybe, 17 fails. That's a NO

predicted NO

testing now for resolution today

predicted NO

@Ernie will you be resolving this now, or at the end of 2023?

predicted NO

warning: I found a bug here, the description says EOY 2023 but due date and title suggest end of nov as the target. Please let me know if this affected you. We may be safe either way since v6 may not come out in 2023 anyway, and even if it does maybe it wouldn't work.

predicted NO

It sounds like V6 or later can probably do this better, but it's not clear when that'll release. Based on today's office hourse, sounds like dec 1 is the optimistic target date.

Bing image creator can sort of do it. "a red triangle on a blue cube"

Reversed prompt somehow is much worse.