Religions are just vehicles used by cultures to codify their present moral and social norms. As such, the mythological scaffolding isn't all that important.

For example, take Roman Catholicism. First of all, if you compare a Roman Catholic from Tanzania to a Roman Catholic from Poland, they will have different takes on quite a few moral and social issues despite both supposedly adhering to the same strict Catechism. Roman Catholics from the US are divided, but neither of the two factions is all that similiar to the Roman Catholics you find in Italy. Instead they are reflections of the political right and left in the US.

Point is, the question is not well posed, because no religion is well defined without additional cultural context. If you asked "is religion A in country ABC in 2026, better than religion B in country XYZ in 2026?", that would be a better posed question. But really, you're trying to compare cultures so talking about religion is again kinda beyond the point.

@PaulManuel Assume both are Indian then.