Skip to main content
MANIFOLD
Will Dan Sullivan lose because of Dan Sullivan? [Short fuse]
21
Ṁ1kṀ3.1k
Nov 6
33%
chance

This market resolves YES if Dan Sullivan and Dan Sullivan's collective votes would have allowed Dan Sullivan to win if Dan Sullivan's votes had been added to his total. Resolves NO if he wins by a greater or lesser margin.

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!
Sort by:

I believe this resolves NO, any objections?

I'm sick with flu for probably a couple more days, will resolve once I'm at my desk again

bought Ṁ50 YES

One thing, What if Dan Sullivan wins? By your own resolution criteria that is a Yes, because Dans Sullivan votes>peltola, but by the title, it requires that neither dan sullivan win.

Betting accordingly to your description of what resolves yes, I see the remaining districts have two very heavy leans toward republicans last season, and only 1 significantly dem leaning district. The current numbers put the DS' votes above peltola by a margin of 3000 whole votes or 1.5%. Market being below 50% is a bit odd.

@OKanon If he wins it resolves NO, this market is about if Dan Sullivan is causing Dan Sullivan to lose.

>Resolves NO if he wins by a greater or lesser margin.

I don't know how this can be interpreted differently.

@Bandors Oh I think I failed to read, my bad, still I believe peltola

I enjoy that this market exists. I don't think I have any information to add to the market with trades, though.

Is this based strictly on the math? As an extreme example, suppose the real Dan Sullivan loses by 100 votes (ignore ties) and, sure enough, the fake Dan Sullivan got exactly 100 votes. But then some voter credibly affirms that they voted intentionally for the fake Dan Sullivan.

That would make the title of this market false but technically a YES by the market description.

Presumably you mean the math answer -- i.e., assume all votes for the fake Dan Sullivan were intended for the real Dan Sullivan -- since the alternative could be a nightmare to adjudicate. But thought I'd clarify just in case!

@dreev For this market I'm going with "assume all votes for the fake Dan Sullivan were intended for the real Dan Sullivan"

bought Ṁ150 NO

rcv complicates things.