Final Edit: I did not change my opinion but I will be rewarding individuals who participated with Mana. Feel free to continue the conversation but I personally need some time to read, understand and reflect on everything that was said. I will reward more bounties than I initially planned because I was not expecting so much engagement. If anyone thinks they deserve more Mana, let me know and I will just send it 😉

I’ve been deeply researching the Israel-Palestine conflict for several weeks. Growing up in Egypt, near Israel, I was always aware of this conflict. As a child, I empathized with the Palestinians. Over time, I sought to understand Israel’s perspective. Books like “The Case for Israel” haven’t yet shifted my view; I still perceive Israel as a state that prioritizes the needs of certain groups, often at significant human cost. This perspective troubles me and seems central to the ongoing problem.

When discussing with Israel’s supporters, conversations often begin with references to the atrocities committed by Hitler and the justification for Israel’s existence. While I recognize the evil of Hitler’s actions and understand the Jewish community’s desire for a safe haven, I don’t believe this justifies displacing others from their homes. The principle of equality is crucial here: Israeli, Palestinian, Jewish, Muslim – all lives are equally valuable.

Moving beyond historical grievances, Israel’s existence is a present reality. However, issues like illegal settlements and the treatment of Palestinians, including night raids and violence, are concerning. These actions continue, even in areas like the West Bank where Hamas is not present. As someone open to diverse perspectives, having even dated a Jewish girl and interacted extensively with Jewish and Israeli people, I still seek convincing arguments that explain Israel’s actions. My current understanding, based on my experiences and readings, leads me to the conclusions I’ve shared.

A striking observation in the discussions I have had is the predominant focus on Israel and Jewish narratives by Israel supporters, with little mention of Palestinian perspectives. This imbalance seems to render Palestinian concerns almost irrelevant, creating a narrative that centers solely around Israel’s right to exist and Jewish historical suffering. Such a one-sided approach is narcissistic, overlooking the complex realities and the rights of all parties involved in the conflict.

No need to respond in the comments. More than happy to jump on a call to discuss if anyone is interested.

Edit: My call for a ceasefire stems from a belief that Israel’s current actions will perpetuate hostility, creating more factions like Hamas. Many Hamas members were radicalized through such actions, expanding of illegal settlements and the unfair treatment of Palestnians. When a child witnesses their home destroyed and their family harmed, it’s difficult to imagine them growing up to advocate for peace. More likely, they may harbor deep resentment and anger towards those responsible for their suffering. This cycle of violence and retaliation seems self-perpetuating, a concern that further complicates the path to a peaceful resolution. I am not justfying the killing of any innocent soul and I hope we don’t twist this conversation towards that.

Edit Two: I am grateful for the responses and will read each and everyone in detail before responding later today. Thank you!