How Friendly is capitalism? Does capitalism optimize for a subset of human values?
32
Never closes
Capitalism optimizes for all human values.
Capitalism optimizes for all human values, but not evenly.
Capitalism optimizes for the values of a subset of humans, and Goodharts the rest.
Capitalism optimizes for some other subset of human values, and Goodharts the rest.
Capitalism optimizes for a set of values that are alien to human values.
Capitalism is not an optimizer.

I kinda just want to see how polls work here.

Edited to add

For a very simplified model, imagine that humans value arbitrarily high amounts of wealth (W) and hugs (H). Human utility U = f(W,H) where f is monotonic in each of W and H.

  1. "Capitalism optimizes for all human values" means that capitalism maximizes U.

  1. "Capitalism optimizes for all human values, but not evenly" means that capitalism maximizes W and H, but perhaps not in the proportions that maximize U. It might be possible to get more U by making less W and more H.¹

  2. "Capitalism optimizes for the values of a subset of humans" means that capitalism might maximize your component of U, and maybe even the U of everyone you know, but not everyone's component of U.

  3. "Capitalism optimizes for some other subset of human values" probably means that capitalism maximizes W, but doesn't maximize H.

  4. "Capitalism optimizes for a set of values that are alien to human values" means that capitalism maximizes some function of X, Y, Z, etc.; where W and H are not functions of X, Y, and Z. (Here live the paperclippers.)

  5. "Capitalism is not an optimizer" means there's no usefully describable A that capitalism maximizes, other than maybe entropy.

¹ And as the old song says, "I don't care too much for W, W can't buy me H."

Get
Ṁ1,000
to start trading!
© Manifold Markets, Inc.TermsPrivacy