Resolution Criteria

This market resolves based on the creator's personal opinion. The creator will determine which answer best reflects their view on the morality of piracy. Resolution occurs when the creator explicitly states their position or indicates which answer aligns with their beliefs.

Background

Piracy—unauthorized copying and distribution of copyrighted content—remains a contested ethical issue. Arguments against piracy emphasize creator compensation and intellectual property rights, while arguments in favor often cite accessibility concerns, fair use principles, or criticism of pricing models. Some distinguish between piracy of different content types (e.g., software vs. entertainment) or contexts (e.g., personal use vs. commercial distribution).

Considerations

The nuance of the "Yes, but only with certain things" option reflects that many people hold conditional moral views on piracy rather than absolute positions. This market captures that spectrum rather than forcing a binary choice.