It will resemble a cake AND it will taste good

It will resemble a cake AND it will taste bad

It will not resemble a cake AND it will taste good

It will not resemble a cake AND it will taste bad

Manifold will be satisfied with the baking and judging process

'bake':7 'judg':9 'manifold':1 'process':10 'satisfi':4

@Mad will make it within a week of the poll closing 

'close':11 'mad':1 'make':3 'poll':10 'week':7 'within':5

As in the tumblr poll, vanilla essence will be the ingredient with the most votes 

'essenc':7 'ingredi':11 'poll':5 'tumblr':4 'vanilla':6 'vote':15

Something will burn while making the cake

When evaluating the taste, @mad will wish she didn't have to choose between "good" and "bad" for resolving the market because it tastes just OK 

'bad':17 'choos':13 'didn':9 'evalu':2 'good':15 'mad':5 'market':21 'ok':26 'resolv':19 'tast':4,24 'wish':7

It will contain more baking powder than milk

It will contain more sugar than vegan egg

Madge will make a single cupcake instead of a full size cake.

'cake':12 'cupcak':6 'full':10 'instead':7 'madg':1 'make':3 'singl':5 'size':11

It will bake with browning on the surface

It will be dense enough to support a full drinking glass (8-12 fl oz) without permanently deforming the crust

'-12':13 '8':12 'crust':20 'deform':18 'dens':4 'drink':10 'enough':5 'fl':14 'full':9 'glass':11 'oz':15 'perman':17 'support':7 'without':16

Based on the above poll I will make a cake. What will the cake be like? Please add responses!

Good and bad and resembling a cake are all subjective concepts, admittedly. As such I won't bet on any subjective items in this market (objective ones like eg if someone adds "it will be less than 50% flour" I might). 

In general, I have a sweet tooth, so something that resembles a milkshake or smoothie might be considered good. Also, if it resembles bread it might be considered good, too. 

Resembling a cake will mean, for the purposes of the market: "was something produced that, after baking, forms a single solid?" - as distinct from "pile of damp flour" or  "milkshake", which are the two extremes of the scale with "resembling a cake" in the centre. That is to say, a literal loaf of bread would qualify as "resembling a cake" for the purposes of this market. As would, I struggle to admit, a cookie or brownie. 

I intend to do my best for this market. If the ingredients skew liquidy, I'll try baking them like macarons, or something (I might solicit advice).

 might also taste it to aid in judging but I'll be the final arbiter. As in all my subjective markets, requests for clarification are solicited.