Currently, the US subsidizes education and gives out massive amounts of student debt.

Provide arguments for whether the government should be involved in the education market in the United States. If the concensus of persuasive arguments/points are in the favor of them being able to, the market resolves YES (NO for they can't). Market resolves based on my subjective opinion of which "side" argued best.

 the arguments in the comments, and consider the validity of the arguments within different values/perspectives other than my own. I will not trade in this market.

Sick dunks and references to data, philosophical/ethical frameworks, or studies, get bonus points.