How many people will quit the US AI Safety Institute as a result of Paul Christiano being hired?
7
136
200
resolved May 17
Resolved
0-1

An article claimed anonymous people would quit the AI Safety Institute if Paul Christiano was hired. Will anyone actually quit?

Most people won't go on record, but a follow up from the original author of the article could take place, so there's a decent chance we'll have evidence to resolve this question.

Get Ṁ600 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ76
2Ṁ15
3Ṁ0
4Ṁ0
Sort by:

Looked like empty attempt to spin up controversy by journalist, when I read the article. But also, how hard would it be to track? How to tell if a resignation is a protest?

@Quinn You're right that it could be hard to know, but maybe not as hard as it seems, for two reasons.

  1. People are pinging the journalist, Sharon Goldman, on Twitter about this, so it's possible she's going to try to talk to whoever she spoke to before and could write a follow-up. It's also possible the journalist didn't speak to anyone, but in my experience, they won't do an article entirely unfounded, though they will sometimes go with very flimsy evidence.

  2. If people resign in protest, they often will make a statement about it.

If we don't see either of these, the question will not resolve.

@WilliamGunn expanding on 2, if it's difficult to tell whether it was a protest resignation, is it really a protest resignation?

The idea of doing a self-sacraficial moral act and then not telling anyone that's what it was is very strange.

@makoyass Yes, absolutely. However, sometimes there are internal discussions that happen between the expression of intent to resign in protest and actually leaving that lead to people leaving quietly. We're not counting leaving quietly as leaving in protest for the purposes of this question, though we may reconsider if an anomalous number of people all leave at once.

More related questions